What Cannot Be Held in an IRA? Prohibited Investments and Smart Alternatives
Understanding what cannot be held in an IRA is essential for any investor looking to maximize retirement savings while staying compliant with IRS regulations. While Individual Retirement Accounts offer tremendous tax advantages and investment flexibility, the IRS explicitly prohibits certain asset classes that could jeopardize your account's tax-advantaged status.
This comprehensive guide explores the specific investments banned from IRAs, including collectibles, life insurance, S-corporation stock, and certain derivatives. More importantly, we'll examine why these restrictions exist, the severe penalties for violations, and smart alternatives that keep your retirement strategy on track while building wealth through real estate and construction investments.
The IRS Rules: What Investments Are Prohibited in an IRA?
The Internal Revenue Code establishes clear boundaries around what assets can and cannot be held in an IRA. Violating these rules triggers severe tax consequences, including potential disqualification of your entire account.
Collectibles: The Most Common Prohibited Investment
Under IRC Section 408(m), IRAs cannot hold collectibles of any kind. The IRS defines collectibles broadly to include:
Prohibited Collectibles:
- Works of art (paintings, sculptures, photographs)
- Rugs and antiques
- Metals (with limited exceptions for certain bullion)
- Gems and jewelry
- Stamps
- Coins (except specific government-minted coins)
- Alcoholic beverages (wine, rare whiskey)
- Historical memorabilia and autographs
- Rare books and manuscripts
Why Collectibles Are Prohibited: The IRS restricts collectibles because their values are subjective, difficult to verify, and prone to manipulation. Unlike publicly traded securities with transparent pricing, collectibles can be easily overvalued or undervalued, creating opportunities for tax abuse.
The Exception for Precious Metals: While most metals are prohibited, certain government-minted coins and bullion meeting specific purity standards are permitted:
- American Eagle coins (gold, silver, platinum)
- American Buffalo gold coins
- Canadian Maple Leaf coins
- Gold bars/rounds with 99.5% or higher purity
- Silver bars/rounds with 99.9% or higher purity
These must be held by an IRS-approved custodian, not stored at home.
Life Insurance: Not Permitted in IRAs
Life insurance policies cannot be held in a traditional or Roth IRA. This prohibition exists because life insurance provides both a death benefit and investment component, and the IRS views this as inconsistent with the retirement savings purpose of IRAs.
What This Means:
- Whole life policies cannot be IRA investments
- Universal life insurance is prohibited
- Variable life insurance is not permitted
- Term life premiums cannot be paid from IRA funds
The 401(k) Exception: While IRAs prohibit life insurance, some employer-sponsored 401(k) plans allow "incidental" life insurance coverage. However, this is subject to strict limitations and is not available for IRA accounts under any circumstances.
S-Corporation Stock: A Surprising Prohibition
Many investors are surprised to learn that S-corporation stock is generally prohibited in IRAs due to the unique tax treatment of S-corps.
Why S-Corp Stock Is Problematic:
S-corporations pass income, losses, and deductions through to shareholders on a pro-rata basis. Since an IRA is a tax-exempt entity, holding S-corp stock creates complications:
- The IRA would receive pass-through income that could be subject to Unrelated Business Income Tax (UBIT)
- S-corps can only have certain types of eligible shareholders, and the IRS historically treated IRAs as ineligible
- The Bank Holding Company Tax Act of 1998 changed some rules, but practical and tax complications remain significant
Practical Reality: While recent regulatory changes have created some pathways for IRA S-corp ownership, most custodians refuse to hold S-corp stock, and the UBIT consequences typically eliminate the tax benefits. For most investors, S-corp stock effectively remains prohibited.
Certain Derivatives and Options
While many derivatives can be held in IRAs, certain complex strategies and leveraged positions are prohibited or restricted:
Prohibited or Restricted Strategies:
- Naked short selling (selling stocks you don't own)
- Margin trading (borrowing to invest within the IRA)
- Futures contracts requiring margin
- Certain complex options strategies
What Is Permitted:
- Covered call options
- Long put and call options
- Certain spread strategies (varies by broker)
- Cash-secured puts
The key restriction is that IRAs cannot use leverage or engage in strategies that could create debt obligations within the account.
Tangible Personal Property
Beyond collectibles, other forms of tangible personal property are generally prohibited:
- Automobiles and vehicles
- Boats and aircraft
- Furniture and household items
- Equipment not used in a business owned by the IRA
- Vacation properties for personal use
If a self-directed IRA purchases real estate, that property cannot be used personally by the IRA owner or their family members.
Consequences of Holding Prohibited Investments
The penalties for holding prohibited investments in an IRA are severe and can devastate your retirement savings.
Immediate Account Disqualification
If you purchase a prohibited investment with IRA funds, the IRS may treat your entire IRA as distributed on the first day of the tax year. This means:
- Full Account Becomes Taxable: The entire IRA balance is treated as ordinary income
- 10% Early Withdrawal Penalty: If you're under 59.5, a 10% penalty applies to the full amount
- Loss of Tax-Advantaged Status: The account's future tax benefits are permanently lost
Example: An investor with a $200,000 traditional IRA purchases $30,000 worth of art. The entire $200,000 could be treated as distributed, resulting in:
- Income tax: $48,000-$74,000 (depending on bracket)
- Early withdrawal penalty: $20,000 (if under 59.5)
- Total cost: $68,000-$94,000 in taxes and penalties
Prohibited Transaction Excise Taxes
Under IRC Section 4975, prohibited transactions trigger excise taxes:
- 15% Initial Tax: Applied to the amount involved in the prohibited transaction
- 100% Additional Tax: If the transaction is not corrected within the taxable period
These taxes are in addition to income taxes and early withdrawal penalties.
Self-Dealing Violations
If the prohibited investment involves self-dealing (transactions between the IRA and the owner or family members), additional consequences apply:
- Immediate disqualification of the IRA
- Potential loss of all tax-deferred growth since the account was established
- IRS scrutiny of other retirement accounts
What CAN Be Held in an IRA? Permitted Investments
Understanding what's permitted helps you maximize IRA benefits while staying compliant.
Traditional Permitted Investments
Stocks and Bonds:
- Individual stocks (domestic and international)
- Corporate bonds
- Government bonds and treasuries
- Municipal bonds
Funds and ETFs:
- Mutual funds
- Exchange-traded funds (ETFs)
- Index funds
- Target-date retirement funds
Cash and Cash Equivalents:
- Money market funds
- Certificates of deposit (CDs)
- Treasury bills
Self-Directed IRA Investments
For investors seeking diversification beyond traditional assets, self-directed IRAs permit:
Real Estate:
- Rental properties
- Commercial buildings
- Raw land
- Real estate investment trusts (REITs)
- Construction projects (with proper structuring)
Alternative Investments:
- Private equity
- LLC membership interests (with limitations)
- Promissory notes
- Certain cryptocurrency (through proper custodians)
- Tax liens and tax deeds
Business Interests:
- C-corporation stock
- LLC interests (in non-S-corp structures)
- Partnership interests
Smart Alternatives: Real Estate and Construction Financing
Rather than attempting to hold prohibited investments in your IRA, consider strategies that build wealth through compliant means while leveraging outside financing for real estate construction.
Keep Your IRA Compliant, Finance Construction Separately
The smartest approach for many investors is maintaining a fully compliant IRA portfolio while using specialized financing for real estate and construction projects.
Benefits of This Approach:
- IRA continues tax-advantaged growth without compliance risk
- Access to construction capital without retirement account penalties
- Leverage amplifies real estate returns
- Diversification across asset classes
DSCR Construction Loans
Debt Service Coverage Ratio (DSCR) loans offer an excellent alternative to using retirement funds for construction projects. These loans qualify based on the property's income potential rather than personal income.
DSCR Loan Advantages:
- No personal tax returns required
- Qualification based on property cash flow
- Works for investment and rental properties
- Available for new construction
- Preserves retirement savings for tax-advantaged growth
Typical Requirements:
- Credit score: 680+
- Down payment: 20-25%
- DSCR ratio: 1.25 or higher projected
- Property must generate rental income
Learn more about DSCR financing options for your construction project.
Bridge Loans for Construction
Bridge loan programs provide flexible short-term financing for construction and development projects while your retirement accounts remain untouched.
Bridge Loan Benefits:
- Fast approval (often 2-3 weeks)
- Flexible qualification standards
- Interest-only payments during construction
- Exit via sale or permanent financing
- No impact on retirement accounts
Bridge financing works particularly well for:
- Ground-up construction
- Property renovation and repositioning
- Acquisition plus construction projects
- Time-sensitive development opportunities
Self-Directed IRA Real Estate (Compliant)
If you want real estate exposure within your IRA, self-directed accounts allow compliant real estate investment:
Requirements for Compliant IRA Real Estate:
- All expenses paid from IRA funds
- All income returns to IRA
- No personal use of property
- No self-dealing with disqualified persons
- Non-recourse financing only (if leveraged)
This approach keeps real estate within the tax-advantaged wrapper while following all IRS rules.
Avoiding Common IRA Investment Mistakes
Understanding common errors helps you avoid costly compliance problems.
Mistake 1: Investing in Friend's S-Corporation
Many investors learn about S-corp restrictions only after making an investment. Before purchasing any private company stock, verify:
- Corporate structure (S-corp vs. C-corp vs. LLC)
- Whether the investment generates UBIT
- Custodian willingness to hold the investment
Mistake 2: Purchasing Collectibles Through a Self-Directed IRA
Self-directed IRA custodians give you more investment flexibility, but collectibles remain prohibited regardless of account type. No custodian arrangement makes artwork or antiques IRA-eligible.
Mistake 3: Storing Precious Metals at Home
Even permitted precious metals (like American Eagle coins) must be stored with an IRS-approved custodian. Home storage, safe deposit boxes, or personal safes trigger prohibited transaction rules.
Mistake 4: Using IRA Property Personally
Self-directed IRA real estate cannot be used by you, your spouse, parents, children, or other disqualified persons. Even one night's personal use can disqualify the entire investment.
Mistake 5: Providing Sweat Equity
If your self-directed IRA owns real estate, you cannot personally perform repairs, maintenance, or improvements. All work must be performed by third parties paid from IRA funds.
Calculating the True Cost of IRA Compliance Errors
Understanding potential costs reinforces the importance of compliance.
Scenario: Prohibited $100,000 Investment
If you invest $100,000 of IRA funds in prohibited assets:
Immediate Costs:
- Income tax (24% bracket): $24,000
- Early withdrawal penalty (if under 59.5): $10,000
- Potential excise tax (15%): $15,000
- Total immediate cost: Up to $49,000
Lost Future Value (assuming 7% annual growth):
- 10-year loss: $96,715
- 20-year loss: $286,968
- 30-year loss: $661,226
The true cost of a prohibited transaction extends far beyond immediate penalties to include decades of lost tax-advantaged compound growth.
Getting Expert Guidance
Given the complexity of IRA investment rules and severe penalties for violations, professional guidance is essential.
When to Consult Professionals
Work with a Tax Professional When:
- Considering any alternative investment in a self-directed IRA
- Unsure whether an investment is permitted
- Discovering a potential prohibited transaction
- Planning significant retirement account decisions
Work with a Financial Advisor When:
- Evaluating self-directed IRA strategies
- Balancing retirement savings with real estate investment goals
- Determining optimal asset allocation
Calculate Your Construction Financing Options
Use our commercial mortgage calculator to compare financing costs and determine whether external construction financing or IRA investment makes more sense for your situation.
Next Steps: Building Wealth While Staying Compliant
Understanding what cannot be held in an IRA empowers you to build wealth through compliant strategies while avoiding costly mistakes.
Action Items
-
Audit Current Holdings: Review your IRA investments to ensure compliance with prohibited investment rules
-
Explore Construction Financing: Contact our team to discuss DSCR loans, bridge financing, and other construction funding options that don't require retirement account access
-
Consider Self-Directed Options: If you want real estate in your retirement portfolio, explore properly structured self-directed IRA investments
-
Calculate the Numbers: Use our commercial mortgage calculator to compare financing options for your construction project
-
Get Professional Guidance: Consult with tax and financial professionals before making significant IRA investment decisions
Conclusion: Protecting Your Retirement While Pursuing Real Estate
The list of what cannot be held in an IRA - collectibles, life insurance, S-corporation stock, and certain derivatives - exists to preserve the integrity of retirement savings vehicles. While these restrictions may seem limiting, they protect investors from complex compliance issues and preserve the tax advantages that make IRAs valuable.
For investors interested in real estate and construction, the smartest approach often involves keeping IRA investments fully compliant while using specialized financing for development projects. DSCR loans, bridge financing, and commercial construction loans provide access to capital for real estate ventures without risking your retirement account's tax-advantaged status.
The cost of prohibited transactions extends far beyond immediate taxes and penalties - it includes decades of lost compound growth that could secure your financial future. By understanding IRA rules and leveraging appropriate financing tools, you can build wealth in real estate while your retirement accounts continue their tax-advantaged growth.
Contact Clear House Lending today to explore construction financing options that fund your real estate projects while protecting your retirement savings.
Start Your Construction Loan Application
Disclaimer: This article provides general information about IRA investment rules and should not be considered legal, tax, or financial advice. IRA regulations are complex, and individual circumstances vary. The information presented reflects current understanding of IRS rules but may change. Consult with qualified tax advisors, financial planners, and legal professionals regarding your specific situation before making investment decisions or changes to retirement accounts.